Attempted Offences



« An attempt is constituted where, having been manifested by the commencement of execution, it was interrupted or failed to achieve its intended result solely because of circumstances beyond the control of its author.. »

Attempted offences are governed and punished under Articles 121-4 and 121-5 of the French Criminal Code.

  1. The Physical Element of an Attempt: Commencement of Execution

According to the Criminal Chamber of the French Court of Cassation, the commencement of execution refers to acts carried out with the intention of committing an offence that "must have the direct and immediate consequence of completing the crime, the latter having entered its execution stage."

An attempted offence therefore requires both: An intention to commit the offence; and An act sufficiently clear and unequivocal to demonstrate that intention.

The commencement of execution is the final stage in the progression towards committing an offence:

  1. Criminal intent
  2. The decision to act
  3. Planning the offence
  4. Preparatory acts
  5. Commencement of execution

Preparatory acts are, in principle, not punishable. An attempt is established only once the offender has moved beyond preparation and begun executing the offence.

  1. The Mental Element of an Attempt

Absence of Voluntary Withdrawal

For an attempt to be punishable, there must be no voluntary withdrawal. This means that the execution of the offence was interrupted against the offender's will because of external circumstances, such as the intervention of law enforcement.

Conversely, where the offender voluntarily abandons the offence before it is completed, the conduct does not constitute a punishable attempt.

For the withdrawal to be regarded as voluntary, it must occur before the offence has been completed.

Note: Voluntary withdrawal is distinct from active repentance, which consists of repairing the harm caused after the offence has already been committed.

The Failed Offence

An attempted offence should not be confused with a failed offence, where the offender completes the criminal act but fails to achieve the intended result because of external circumstances.

For example, this may occur where a person fires a gun at another individual but misses.

A failed offence is treated and punished in the same way as an attempted offence.

The Impossible Offence

An impossible offence arises where completion of the offence is impossible because of circumstances unknown to the offender.

For example, a person breaks the window of a car intending to steal property inside, only to discover that the vehicle is empty.

In this situation: The commencement of execution is established by breaking the window. There is no voluntary withdrawal, since the offender only abandoned the theft because there was nothing to steal.

Such an offence is treated and punished in the same manner as an attempted offence.


Penalties

Where both of the following elements are established: Commencement of execution; and Absence of voluntary withdrawal, the offender may be prosecuted for an attempted offence.

Under Article 121-4 of the French Criminal Code, a person is considered to be the perpetrator of an offence if they:

  • « Commit the prohibited acts; or ;
  • Attempt to commit a crime or, where expressly provided by law, a misdemeanour. ».

Accordingly, the penalties for an attempted offence are the same as those applicable to the completed offence.

An attempt to commit a crime is always punishable. By contrast, an attempt to commit a misdemeanour is punishable only where expressly provided by law, as is the case for offences such as sexual assault and theft.



Your Criminal Defense with Maître Lois Pamela LESOT

Have you been the victim of, or accused in, a criminal case?
Consult a lawyer: Maître Lois Pamela LESOT – 06.52.02.54.42 – lesot@loispamelalesot.com

The law firm regularly assists and defends individuals who are victims or accused in criminal cases such as rape, blackmail, or abuse of vulnerability.

If you wish to file a criminal complaint, you can consult this article.
If you are accused, you can prepare for police custody by consulting this article and for a voluntary interview by consulting this article.


Article date: November 18, 2025 | By Lois Pamela LESOT